The verse form was famous for decades before anyone called it a limerick. Edward Lear, the poet most tied to it, never used the word.

Lear's A Book of Nonsense appeared in 1846, though World Wide Words says it only became well known with the 1861 third edition, the first to name him. He called his pieces "nonsenses" or "old persons." Even Lear was not first. World Wide Words points to little books from 1820 to 1822, such as Anecdotes and Adventures of Fifteen Gentlemen, which called the verses "anecdotes" or "histories." Lear found one of those books in the 1830s at Knowsley Hall, near Liverpool.

The name arrives late. The first known use of "limerick" for these poems is in an 1896 letter by the illustrator Aubrey Beardsley. That gap of half a century is why the origin is so hard to pin down.

The most quoted explanation is a party game. The Oxford English Dictionary says guests took turns improvising a nonsense verse, and everyone then joined a chorus that mentioned Limerick. Britannica gives the refrain as "Will You Come Up to Limerick?", from an Irish soldiers' song. But the clearest description of the game, from a correspondent to Notes and Queries, dates only to December 1898. That is after Beardsley's letter, so the story may explain the word, or the word may have colored the story. World Wide Words still leans toward a party chorus, sung in Britain.

There are rival ideas. Some books on Ireland credit the Maigue poets, an 18th-century circle of Gaelic poets who met in a pub in Croom, County Limerick, and wrote in limerick metre. World Wide Words calls the dating and transmission behind that claim weak. Another theory links the refrain to "come to Limerick," American Civil War slang for facing up to a challenge, first recorded in 1860. World Wide Words calls that idea intriguing but speculative.

Britannica's verdict is blunt: the origin of the limerick is unknown. What is clear is the city in the name and the timing. The form came first, Lear made it popular, and the label was attached around the 1890s, probably in Britain.