Rhetoric has had a bad name since ancient times. Etymonline notes that even in classical times the word carried a sense of artificial speech, set against what was natural and unaffected.

The Greek source is rhētōr, a speaker or master speaker. In Athens it meant especially a public orator. Rhētorikē tekhnē was the orator's art. Rhētōr is related to rhēsis, "speech," and rhēma, "word." Etymonline reconstructs a Proto-Indo-European root, were-, "to speak," which also produced the Greek eirein, "to say," and the Old English word.

Greek philosophers argued about its worth. In the Gorgias, written around 386 BC, Plato treats rhetoric as immoral, dangerous and unworthy of serious study. His Phaedrus, a little later, takes a milder line.

Aristotle took it seriously. His treatise, the Rhetoric, was developed during his two periods in Athens in the 4th century BC. It opens by calling rhetoric the counterpart of dialectic. Aristotle defines rhetoric as the ability, in any given case, to see the available means of persuasion. He groups those means under three heads: the speaker's credibility, the audience's emotions, and the reasoning itself. Most rhetoricians regard it as the most important single work on persuasion ever written.

English took the word in the early 1300s as rethorike, meaning the art of eloquence and persuasiveness in language. It came through Old French retorike and Latin rhetorice. The word for the teacher, rhetor, followed in the late 1300s.

In medieval schooling, rhetoric was one of the three subjects of the trivium, with grammar and logic. Together they formed the lower tier of the seven liberal arts, beneath the quadrivium of arithmetic, geometry, music and astronomy. Grammar dealt with how language works, and logic with what is certainly true or false. Rhetoric applied language to instruct and to persuade.

Persuasion can serve a good argument or dress up a bad one. That is why the word has carried both a respected and a suspect meaning since classical times.