The upshot of an argument was once a real arrow, the last one loosed in an archery contest.

The first edition of the Oxford English Dictionary, reprinted online as the World English Historical Dictionary, gives the original sense as the final shot in an archery match. Its earliest example is from 1531, in Henry VIII's privy purse accounts. A payment is made to an archer called Coton "for one up shotte that he wanne of the kinges grace." Dictionary.com gives the same history: in the 16th century the last arrow in an archery competition was called the upshot.

The word is plain English. Dictionary.com breaks it into up- and shot. Shot itself, Etymonline says, meant "a missile, arrow, dart" in Middle English, from Old English scot. The Dictionary of the Older Scottish Tongue lists the early English spellings up shotte (1531) and vpshot (1575).

The meaning then moved away from the target. The same dictionary records a now obsolete sense, the mark or end aimed at. Spenser wrote in 1591 of "the onely vpshot whereto he doth ayme." An example from 1754 reads: "The Upshot of all Religion is to please God." Another early sense was simply an end or conclusion.

The modern meaning, the result of a course of action, appears in 1604 in Hamlet: "And in this vpshot, purposes mistooke." The dictionary notes that this sense became very frequent from about 1830. Scottish writers used it too. A 1676 preface quoted in the Dictionary of the Older Scottish Tongue says, "But the uppshott of all they made the bande of mutwal defence."

So the shift is easy to follow. The final arrow decided who won. From there the word came to mean whatever finally decides or sums up a matter. Dictionary.com still lists "the final shot in a match" as an archery sense in British English, next to "the final result."

Today the word has drifted again. Grammarist notes that upshot is often used to mean an advantage or benefit. It suggests the cause is its sound, close to upside.

The archery contests are gone from daily life, but the word for their last arrow is still in use. It now closes meetings and memos instead of matches.